shibboleth-dev - Re: [Shib-Dev] Return of the Java SP... again

Subject: Shibboleth Developers

List archive

Re: [Shib-Dev] Return of the Java SP... again

From: Chad La Joie <>
To:
Subject: Re: [Shib-Dev] Return of the Java SP... again
Date: Wed, 25 Aug 2010 15:32:00 -0400
Organization: Itumi, LLC

I would feel uncomfortable doing that. It feels like it would be encouraging a bad practice. Like you I don't get super freaked about pushing unencrypted attributes but I do feel it's not the ideal situation.

On 8/25/10 3:29 PM, Scott Cantor wrote:

Well, I think the problem is that there is quite a large SAML 1 only
install base right now and a lot of them aren't show much sign of
moving. We still know there are a significant number of folks running
Shib 1.3 and many of the other opensource IdPs are are SAML 1 only.

I guess a compromise with possibly useful side effects is not supporting
queries, so people would have to push attributes in the client with no
encryption. That seems to bug people, so I guess that's a way of
accomodating without encouraging.

-- Scott

--
Chad La Joie
http://itumi.biz
trusted identities, delivered

Re: [Shib-Dev] Return of the Java SP... again, (continued)
- Re: [Shib-Dev] Return of the Java SP... again, RL 'Bob' Morgan, 08/25/2010
  - Re: [Shib-Dev] Return of the Java SP... again, Chad La Joie, 08/25/2010
    - RE: [Shib-Dev] Return of the Java SP... again, Scott Cantor, 08/25/2010
      - Re: [Shib-Dev] Return of the Java SP... again, Chad La Joie, 08/25/2010
        
        Re: [Shib-Dev] Return of the Java SP... again, Jim Fox, 08/26/2010
        
        Re: [Shib-Dev] Return of the Java SP... again, Nate Klingenstein, 08/26/2010
        
        [Shib-Dev] Possible to provide shib-common/opensaml snapshots as well?, Halm Reusser, 08/26/2010
        
        Re: [Shib-Dev] Return of the Java SP... again, Ian Young, 08/26/2010
      - Re: [Shib-Dev] Return of the Java SP... again, Ian Young, 08/26/2010
        
        Re: [Shib-Dev] Return of the Java SP... again, Chad La Joie, 08/26/2010
    - Re: [Shib-Dev] Return of the Java SP... again, Paul Hethmon, 08/25/2010
    - Re: [Shib-Dev] Return of the Java SP... again, Peter Schober, 08/25/2010
      - RE: [Shib-Dev] Return of the Java SP... again, Scott Cantor, 08/25/2010
- Re: [Shib-Dev] Return of the Java SP... again, Peter Schober, 08/26/2010

List archive

Re: [Shib-Dev] Return of the Java SP... again