wg-multicast - Re: I rest my case
Subject: All things related to multicast
List archive
- From: Andrew Swan <>
- To: wg-multicast <>
- Subject: Re: I rest my case
- Date: Wed, 26 May 2004 18:47:35 -0700
Charles R. Anderson wrote:
> Interestingly, though, our switches do support IGMPv3 snooping--it is
> the client suuport that is lacking. And since there is no way to
> gradually migrate from IGMPv2 to IGMPv3, I can't support SSM at all
> until all the clients are upgraded.
can you elaborate on that last point? we're running a mixed
v2-v3 network here and as far as i know everything is working
smoothly... according to rfc 3376, the router decides
separately for each group which protocol version to use
depending on the presence of igmpv2-only hosts in the group.
and my understanding is that some routers can be configured
to ignore igmpv2 (or v1) messages for groups in 232.x.x.x so
an igmpv2-only host cannot break ssm by forcing an ssm group
into v2 compatability mode.
-Andrew
- Re: I rest my case, (continued)
- Re: I rest my case, Alan Crosswell, 05/22/2004
- Re: I rest my case, John Zwiebel, 05/22/2004
- Re: I rest my case, Alan Crosswell, 05/22/2004
- Re: I rest my case, Ross Finlayson, 05/23/2004
- Re: I rest my case, Hitoshi Asaeda, 05/23/2004
- Re: I rest my case, John Zwiebel, 05/23/2004
- Re: I rest my case, William F. Maton, 05/25/2004
- Re: I rest my case, John Zwiebel, 05/22/2004
- Re: I rest my case, Marshall Eubanks, 05/22/2004
- Re: I rest my case, Joel Jaeggli, 05/24/2004
- Re: I rest my case, Charles R. Anderson, 05/24/2004
- Re: I rest my case, Andrew Swan, 05/26/2004
- Re: I rest my case, Hitoshi Asaeda, 05/27/2004
- Re: I rest my case, Andrew Swan, 05/26/2004
- Re: I rest my case, Charles R. Anderson, 05/24/2004
- Re: I rest my case, debbie fligor, 05/25/2004
- Re: I rest my case, Joel Jaeggli, 05/24/2004
- RE: I rest my case, Richard Mavrogeanes, 05/22/2004
- Re: I rest my case, Dan Pritts, 05/23/2004
- Re: I rest my case, Marshall Eubanks, 05/23/2004
- Re: I rest my case, John Zwiebel, 05/23/2004
- Re: I rest my case, Dan Pritts, 05/23/2004
- RE: I rest my case, Richard Mavrogeanes, 05/23/2004
- Re: I rest my case, Dan Pritts, 05/23/2004
- RE: I rest my case, Richard Mavrogeanes, 05/23/2004
- RE: I rest my case, Richard Mavrogeanes, 05/23/2004
- Re: I rest my case, Alan Crosswell, 05/22/2004
Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.16.