wg-multicast - Re: [NTAC] Fwd: AS 20130 has turned off interdomain IP multicast
Subject: All things related to multicast
List archive
- From: Garret Peirce <>
- To: Havard Eidnes <>
- Cc: , , "<>" <>
- Subject: Re: [NTAC] Fwd: AS 20130 has turned off interdomain IP multicast
- Date: Thu, 18 Aug 2016 10:17:27 -0400
- Ironport-phdr: 9a23:o9KNABPYGQ5IIQWZ8QQl6mtUPXoX/o7sNwtQ0KIMzox0K/TyrarrMEGX3/hxlliBBdydsK0UzbeN+Pm9EUU7or+/81k6OKRWUBEEjchE1ycBO+WiTXPBEfjxciYhF95DXlI2t1uyMExSBdqsLwaK+i76xXcoFx7+LQt4IPjuUs6X1pzvlrP6x5qGQwxWjSCxKZ5zIBO7tk2FtsQ+h4x4Jrt3zBbV9ChmYeNTkExhP0ieg17E68aq95Mrpzxduugq+uZFWKT8cuI1QaEOX2duCHw8+MC+7UqLdgCI/HZJFzxOyhc=
>At least "plain IPv6 unicast", doesn't suffer from any corresponding
>deployment bug, if that's anything to learn from. Imagine where we'd
>be with IPv6 unicast deployment today if a single IPv4 host could
--
>deployment bug, if that's anything to learn from. Imagine where we'd
>be with IPv6 unicast deployment today if a single IPv4 host could
>through its mere existence veto IPv6 use on that subnet.
Well...unless one calls v6 rogue RAs and the immediate resulting DoS a unicast v6 deployment bug. ;-)
Only mitigated by snooping/filtering at L2 which one could consider similar extra complexity to make unicast v6 viable.
Agree re: comments on IGMP v2/v3 as well as the consensus shift I read here towards SSM-only for interdomain.
I hesitate to abandon a tool such as interdomain mcast, just because of technical complexity.
That complexity might influence a solution, but the service need should be steering the car, not the other way around. The need for interdomain mcast is admittedly low to non-existent, but like to think 1->many just hasn't found it's killer app yet.
ASM is still up here for now, but just as Bryant Pond, ME was last to have hand-crank phone service,
including party line service , perhaps we aim for that interdomain ASM trophy too.
- Re: AS 20130 has turned off interdomain IP multicast, (continued)
- Re: AS 20130 has turned off interdomain IP multicast, Bruce Curtis, 08/11/2016
- Re: AS 20130 has turned off interdomain IP multicast, Michael H Lambert, 08/11/2016
- Re: AS 20130 has turned off interdomain IP multicast, John Kristoff, 08/10/2016
- Re: AS 20130 has turned off interdomain IP multicast, Michael H Lambert, 08/10/2016
- Message not available
- Re: [NTAC] Fwd: AS 20130 has turned off interdomain IP multicast, David Farmer, 08/10/2016
- Re: [NTAC] Fwd: AS 20130 has turned off interdomain IP multicast, Tristan Rhodes, 08/10/2016
- Re: [NTAC] Fwd: AS 20130 has turned off interdomain IP multicast, David Farmer, 08/10/2016
- Message not available
- Re: [NTAC] Fwd: AS 20130 has turned off interdomain IP multicast, Alan Whinery, 08/10/2016
- Re: [NTAC] Fwd: AS 20130 has turned off interdomain IP multicast, Leonard Giuliano, 08/17/2016
- Re: [NTAC] Fwd: AS 20130 has turned off interdomain IP multicast, Havard Eidnes, 08/18/2016
- Re: [NTAC] Fwd: AS 20130 has turned off interdomain IP multicast, Garret Peirce, 08/18/2016
- Re: [NTAC] Fwd: AS 20130 has turned off interdomain IP multicast, Brent Draney, 08/18/2016
- Re: [NTAC] Fwd: AS 20130 has turned off interdomain IP multicast, Leonard Giuliano, 08/18/2016
- Re: [NTAC] Fwd: AS 20130 has turned off interdomain IP multicast, Leonard Giuliano, 08/17/2016
- Re: [NTAC] Fwd: AS 20130 has turned off interdomain IP multicast, Dan Pritts, 08/18/2016
- Re: [NTAC] Fwd: AS 20130 has turned off interdomain IP multicast, Dan Pritts, 08/18/2016
- Re: [NTAC] Fwd: AS 20130 has turned off interdomain IP multicast, Alan Whinery, 08/10/2016
- Re: [NTAC] Fwd: AS 20130 has turned off interdomain IP multicast, Tristan Rhodes, 08/10/2016
- Re: [NTAC] Fwd: AS 20130 has turned off interdomain IP multicast, David Farmer, 08/10/2016
- Re: AS 20130 has turned off interdomain IP multicast, Bruce Curtis, 08/11/2016
- Re: [NTAC] Fwd: AS 20130 has turned off interdomain IP multicast, Bill Owens, 08/10/2016
- Re: [NTAC] Fwd: AS 20130 has turned off interdomain IP multicast, David Farmer, 08/10/2016
- Re: [NTAC] Fwd: AS 20130 has turned off interdomain IP multicast, Jimmy Kyriannis, 08/11/2016
- Re: [NTAC] Fwd: AS 20130 has turned off interdomain IP multicast, Bill Owens, 08/11/2016
- Re: [NTAC] Fwd: AS 20130 has turned off interdomain IP multicast, Bruce Curtis, 08/11/2016
- Re: [NTAC] Fwd: AS 20130 has turned off interdomain IP multicast, Havard Eidnes, 08/12/2016
- Re: [NTAC] Fwd: AS 20130 has turned off interdomain IP multicast, David Farmer, 08/10/2016
Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.19.