wg-multicast - Re: Another SAP Storm?
Subject: All things related to multicast
List archive
- From: Marshall Eubanks <>
- To: Leonard Giuliano <>
- Cc: Dave Diller <>, Pekka Savola <>, wg-multicast List <>
- Subject: Re: Another SAP Storm?
- Date: Wed, 11 Jun 2008 23:12:10 -0400
On Jun 11, 2008, at 5:43 PM, Leonard Giuliano wrote:
Keep in mind that SAP is useful for some apps like SDR, VLC, IPTV, etc.
Policing the entire SAP group to 1Mbps just makes it easier to DOS SAP-
now you only need to send 1Mbps of mcast data at the SAP group and no good
SAP packets will get through either, effectively taking down the entire
SAP service.
Routers have no problems with high SAP data rates. They will happily
forward them with no problems. The problem happens when you tell the
routers to listen to these SAP announcements.
Listening to SAP messages was once a nice, quick and easy way to see if
mcast was working. The benefit may not be worth the risk anymore. May
want to think about simply turning off SAP listening on the routers
(delete protocols sap / no sdr listen).
I keep thinking that after each SAP storm there won't be any more people with routers listening to SAP,
which sounds very archaic to me. Why does this keep coming up ? Is there some default router config
that needs to be changed.
Regards
Marshall
This will still forward the SAP announcements to the intended receiving
hosts, it just won't cache these messages on the routers.
-Lenny
- Re: Another SAP Storm?, (continued)
- Re: Another SAP Storm?, Chris Robb, 06/11/2008
- Re: Another SAP Storm?, Pekka Savola, 06/11/2008
- Re: Another SAP Storm?, Niels den Otter, 06/11/2008
- Re: Another SAP Storm?, Pekka Savola, 06/11/2008
- Re: Another SAP Storm?, Dave Diller, 06/11/2008
- Re: Another SAP Storm?, Leonard Giuliano, 06/11/2008
- Re: Another SAP Storm?, Julian Y. Koh, 06/11/2008
- Re: Another SAP Storm?, Bill Owens, 06/11/2008
- Re: Another SAP Storm?, A . L . M . Buxey, 06/11/2008
- Re: Another SAP Storm?, Dave Diller, 06/11/2008
- Re: Another SAP Storm?, Marshall Eubanks, 06/11/2008
- Re: Another SAP Storm?, Chris Spears, 06/11/2008
- Re: Another SAP Storm?, Zenon Mousmoulas, 06/11/2008
- Re: Another SAP Storm?, Niels den Otter, 06/12/2008
- Re: Another SAP Storm?, Zenon Mousmoulas, 06/12/2008
- Re: Another SAP Storm?, Zenon Mousmoulas, 06/11/2008
- Re: Another SAP Storm?, Hank Nussbacher, 06/12/2008
- Re: Another SAP Storm?, Zenon Mousmoulas, 06/12/2008
- Re: Another SAP Storm?, John Watters, 06/12/2008
- Re: Another SAP Storm?, Jean-François Florence, 06/12/2008
- Re: Another SAP Storm?, Frank Fulchiero, 06/12/2008
Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.16.