Shibboleth Developers

["Scott Cantor" <>]

> Granted. I'm not disputing that consent isn't sometimes necessary to
> support the types of use-cases you suggested. There is a certainly a
> place for consent-management tools but I don't believe that the
> requirement is as general as people sometimes think, particularly in
> educational sectors other than HE, such as schools (~K12), where the
> learning environment is subject to much tighter control.

I definitely agree with that. My biggest complaint, as I said in the
original email, is that we have paralysis by analysis here by trying to
design full attribute release instead of just generic consent for certain
classes of services.

-- Scott