wg-multicast - Re: Why don't we use multicast more often?
Subject: All things related to multicast
List archive
- From: Dan Hague <>
- To: Bob Riddle <>
- Cc: , Mike Clancy <>, Eric Wolf <>
- Subject: Re: Why don't we use multicast more often?
- Date: Sun, 16 May 2004 00:11:40 -0400
Bob,
We plan to enable multicast for a large portion of the University of Michigan campus during 2004. We are starting with the Music School and have a half dozen other requests in process. The drivers are DVTS, Access Grid and future television services via some vendor like Video Furnace, VBrick, Cflix or Campus TeleVideo...
-Dan
On May 14, 2004, at 03:36 PM, Bob Riddle wrote:
perhaps we could put some "how to configure mulitcast for your XXXX router" up on the wg working pages? Any volunteers willing to contribute the story on how they configured multicast?R. Daniel Hague, BSEE, FE
Bill Owens wrote:
On Thu, May 13, 2004 at 04:24:36PM -0400, Richard Mavrogeanes wrote:
My two cents:. . .
Multicast is not used more often because:
1. The default condition of virtually all routers is to disable multicast.
All true, and I certainly know that multicast is not an easy thing to configure, manage and repair (or even understand!) but I'm intentionally preaching the choir here. I wasn't asking why Joe Public doesn't use multicast more often, I was asking why *we* don't use it more often.
My application, weekly recurring conference calls with a standing group of people, all at Internet2 sites, all of them advanced network users, seems like an ideal place to use multicast a/v tools - and yet, we don't. There must be dozens of similar conference calls every week; heck, Internet2 has their own conference system, and they wouldn't have bothered if they didn't use it a lot. Isn't there something wrong with that picture?
Bill.
--
Bob Riddle () Technologist,Internet2
3025 Boardwalk, Suite 100 Ann Arbor, Michigan 48108
Business Phone: 734.913.4257 Fax Number: 734.913.4255
"Math illiteracy affects 7 out of every 5 people"
Senior Engineer | Voice 734-763-9378
Information Technology Department | Fax 734-936-1439
University of Michigan | Web www.umich.edu/~dhague
4251 Plymouth Road, Room 2214c | Email
Ann Arbor, MI 48105 | Video by appointment
- Re: Why don't we use multicast more often?, (continued)
- Re: Why don't we use multicast more often?, Leonard Giuliano, 05/13/2004
- Re: Why don't we use multicast more often?, Chris Rapier, 05/14/2004
- Re: Why don't we use multicast more often?, Chris Rapier, 05/14/2004
- Re: Why don't we use multicast more often?, Greg Shepherd, 05/14/2004
- Re: Why don't we use multicast more often?, Chris Rapier, 05/14/2004
- Re: Why don't we use multicast more often?, Joel Jaeggli, 05/14/2004
- Re: Why don't we use multicast more often?, Marshall Eubanks, 05/14/2004
- Re: Why don't we use multicast more often?, Chris Rapier, 05/14/2004
- Re: Why don't we use multicast more often?, Chris Rapier, 05/14/2004
- Re: Why don't we use multicast more often?, Bob Riddle, 05/14/2004
- Re: Why don't we use multicast more often?, Brent Sweeny, 05/14/2004
- Re: Why don't we use multicast more often?, William F. Maton, 05/14/2004
- Re: Why don't we use multicast more often?, Dan Hague, 05/16/2004
- Re: Why don't we use multicast more often?, Greg Shepherd, 05/13/2004
- RE: Why don't we use multicast more often?, Richard Mavrogeanes, 05/13/2004
- RE: Why don't we use multicast more often?, Kevin C. Almeroth, 05/14/2004
- Re: Why don't we use multicast more often?, Bob Riddle, 05/14/2004
- Why don't we use multicast more often?, John Watters, 05/14/2004
- RE: Why don't we use multicast more often?, Paul Gilbert, 05/14/2004
- Re: Why don't we use multicast more often?, Bob Riddle, 05/14/2004
- Re: Why don't we use multicast more often?, William F. Maton, 05/14/2004
- RE: Why don't we use multicast more often?, Michael Hallgren, 05/14/2004
- RE: Why don't we use multicast more often?, Richard Mavrogeanes, 05/14/2004
- Re: Why don't we use multicast more often?, Leonard Giuliano, 05/13/2004
Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.16.