wg-multicast - On avoiding the need to require snooping switches
Subject: All things related to multicast
List archive
- From: Guy T Almes <>
- To: Alan Crosswell <>, "Kevin C. Almeroth" <>
- Cc:
- Subject: On avoiding the need to require snooping switches
- Date: Fri, 09 Aug 2002 14:35:19 -0400
M'casters,
I would also be interested in comments on Bill Nickless's note.
SSM does seem to solve the wide-area source-discovery problem and let us avoid using or improving on MSDP.
But I hope that Bill's issue (on the need to improve on our current habit of imposing on L2 switch vendors to snoop intelligently) will receive serious attention.
So much of what makes the Internet powerful is the minimal constraints it imposes on L1/L2 protocols. The result is often wonderful cost-effectiveness resulting from a nice variety of cheap fast robust L1/L2 technologies with IP layered neatly on top. The demands of multicast for snooping seem to go counter to that generally strong attribute of Internet engineering.
Regards,
-- Guy
--On Wednesday, August 07, 2002 10:09:54 -0400 Alan Crosswell <> wrote:
Can someone explain to me how one uses SSM to do something intrinsically
easy for ASM: discover the existence of unknown sources?
/a
- Re: IPv6 Multicast, (continued)
- Re: IPv6 Multicast, Kevin C. Almeroth, 08/07/2002
- Re: IPv6 Multicast, Marshall Eubanks, 08/07/2002
- Re: IPv6 Multicast, Bill Owens, 08/07/2002
- Re: IPv6 Multicast, Kevin C. Almeroth, 08/07/2002
- Re: IPv6 Multicast, Marshall Eubanks, 08/07/2002
- Re: IPv6 Multicast - ASM vs. SSM, Bill Owens, 08/07/2002
- Re: IPv6 Multicast, Marshall Eubanks, 08/07/2002
- RE: IPv6 Multicast, Michael Luby, 08/07/2002
- RE: IPv6 Multicast, Greg Shepherd, 08/07/2002
- Re: IPv6 Multicast, Marshall Eubanks, 08/07/2002
- Re: IPv6 Multicast, Guy T Almes, 08/09/2002
- On avoiding the need to require snooping switches, Guy T Almes, 08/09/2002
- Re: On avoiding the need to require snooping switches, Tim Ward, 08/09/2002
- Re: On avoiding the need to require snooping switches, Havard Eidnes, 08/09/2002
- Re: On avoiding the need to require snooping switches, John Kristoff, 08/09/2002
- Re: On avoiding the need to require snooping switches, Guy T Almes, 08/12/2002
- Re: On avoiding the need to require snooping switches, Bill Nickless, 08/13/2002
- Re: IPv6 Multicast, Alan Crosswell, 08/07/2002
- Re: IPv6 Multicast, Kevin C. Almeroth, 08/07/2002
- Re: IPv6 Multicast, Alan Crosswell, 08/07/2002
- Re: IPv6 Multicast, Joel Jaeggli, 08/07/2002
- RE: IPv6 Multicast, Alan Crosswell, 08/07/2002
- Re: IPv6 Multicast, Kevin C. Almeroth, 08/07/2002
Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.16.