Shibboleth Developers

["Cantor, Scott E." <>]

>I would be happy to lobby Internet2 for *something* but the shib
>project has to tell me what to lobby *for*. I'm not hearing consensus
>from the shib team on this issue.

I think the *team* has consensus (of course, others besides Chad and
myself may say otherwise) that permanent redirects are a mistake.

That doesn't mean the *community* agrees, and all I was saying was that we
don't really have any say, ultimately, if the community asks I2 to keep
them there and I2 agrees. My response would be "ok, but you'll be running
them forever until at some point you can't, and then the break will be
unplanned and sloppy".

-- Scott