wg-multicast - Re: So we need some scoping for non-global I2 multicast groups
Subject: All things related to multicast
List archive
- From: David Meyer <>
- To: (Wallace Steven S)
- Cc: , , , , ,
- Subject: Re: So we need some scoping for non-global I2 multicast groups
- Date: Thu, 1 Jul 1999 07:14:31 -0700 (PDT)
What Steve said. It's private G, not private S that
we need if we want to do this kind of scoping.
Dave
According to Wallace, Steven S:
>
> >
> > It would seem to me that if you want to keep something from
> > leaking out of
> > I2, you need to put up a private "source" address range. Say assign a
> > subset of this source range to each I2 member via a glop
> > agorithm. Using
> > this method, mbgp and msdp scoping could be applied to deny
> > this private S
> > information from leaking to commodity I1 service (which is probably
> > already configured intrinsitically by not having already
> > defined these in
> > a route-map permit type config) and thusly prevent (S,G)
> > state from being
> > built.
> >
>
> I would think blocking sources would break RPF, potentially causing routing
> loops. If there's an (*,g), the packet is going to get forwarded, just not
> via a source based tree...and if there's not mbgp information preventing the
> packet from looping back to the source, not good.
>
> Steven
>
- RE: So we need some scoping for non-global I2 multicast groups, Wallace, Steven S, 07/01/1999
- Re: So we need some scoping for non-global I2 multicast groups, David Meyer, 07/01/1999
- Re: So we need some scoping for non-global I2 multicast groups, Gordon Rogier, 07/01/1999
- <Possible follow-up(s)>
- Re: So we need some scoping for non-global I2 multicast groups, Mark Fullmer, 07/01/1999
- Re: So we need some scoping for non-global I2 multicast groups, David Meyer, 07/02/1999
- Message not available
- Re: So we need some scoping for non-global I2 multicast groups, Mark Fullmer, 07/07/1999
- Re: So we need some scoping for non-global I2 multicast groups, Bill Fenner, 07/07/1999
- Re: So we need some scoping for non-global I2 multicast groups, Havard . Eidnes, 07/07/1999
- Re: So we need some scoping for non-global I2 multicast groups, Bill Fenner, 07/07/1999
- Re: So we need some scoping for non-global I2 multicast groups, Hugh LaMaster, 07/09/1999
- Re: So we need some scoping for non-global I2 multicast groups, Hugh LaMaster, 07/09/1999
- Re: So we need some scoping for non-global I2 multicast groups, Gordon Rogier, 07/10/1999
- Re: So we need some scoping for non-global I2 multicast groups, Bill Fenner, 07/07/1999
- Re: So we need some scoping for non-global I2 multicast groups, Havard . Eidnes, 07/07/1999
- Re: So we need some scoping for non-global I2 multicast groups, Bill Fenner, 07/07/1999
- Re: So we need some scoping for non-global I2 multicast groups, Mark Fullmer, 07/07/1999
- Re: So we need some scoping for non-global I2 multicast groups, David Meyer, 07/01/1999
Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.16.