COmanage Developers List

[Niels van Dijk <>]

Hi Ben,

On 07/22/2010 05:45 PM, Benn Oshrin wrote:
> On 7/22/10 9:07 AM, Niels van Dijk wrote:
> > Also in regard to the above page: I understand that presenting the
> level
> > of domestication is a tricky issue. However I think it would be nice if
> > it were possible to have an overview where one can quickly grasp the
> > level of maturity in the blink of an eye. Could we give the different
> > levels a 'common' name and reverse the order? So poorly the current
> > "level5" domesticated app gets one or no points and level 1a gets 5
> > points or starts or something? That would make that '*Overall
> > certification of Domestication*' is no longer required as  having 5
> > points automatically is the highest level. For a rough example, see the
> > attached screenshot.
>
> By way of background, the I2 wiki page was the result of 90 minutes of
> free association and is not necessarily coherent :)  We definitely
> need to spend more time thinking about the proper labels/levels/etc. 
> Your comments are a step in the right direction.
>

For a 90 min. effort it is a very good start ;) I took it as a first
setup and a rfc.


> > Some other issues that came to mind:
> > - What if multiple implementations exist (as we seem to have for
> > confluence already)
>
> Probably one entry with sub-entries, score based on the "best"
> implementation if that's possible.
Sounds like a good idea indeed,
I'll add a few more examples to see if these can be matched in the
current setup

cheers,
Niels
>
> > - What if multiple version of the same product have different states of
> > domestication? In general I think we could solve this by only having
> the
> > most current version of the product on the wiki domestication
> frontpage,
> > and refer to older versions in a page behind the overview page.
>
> Yeah, again one entry with sub-entries.
>
> -Benn-

-- 
Niels van Dijk
Advanced Services

T: +31 302 305 337 / M: +31 651 347 657
SURFnet - PO Box 19035 - NL-3501 DA Utrecht - The Netherlands -

http://www.surfnet.nl
SURFnet - We make innovation work

begin:vcard
fn:Niels van Dijk
n:van Dijk;Niels
org:SURFnet;Advanced Services
adr:;;PO Box 19035;Utrecht;;NL-3501-DA;The Netherlands
email;internet:
tel;work:+31 302 305 337
tel;fax:+31 302 305 329
tel;cell:+31 651 347 657
url:www.surfnet.nl
version:2.1
end:vcard