wg-multicast - Re: Cisco IPv4 Multicast Issue
Subject: All things related to multicast
List archive
- From: Bill Owens <>
- To: Toerless Eckert <>
- Cc: Michael Forrest <>, , Chi-Che Hou <>, Andrew Kessler <>
- Subject: Re: Cisco IPv4 Multicast Issue
- Date: Tue, 2 May 2006 09:29:48 -0400
On Mon, May 01, 2006 at 08:49:42PM -0700, Toerless Eckert wrote:
>
> c) In general we recommend not to enable SAP, so i am very interested
> to get a reinforcement about how useful this command still is
> to common user practices ;-)) After all:
We turned off the command years ago, when the first problems showed up. Have
never turned it back on, and have never missed it. I have always been in the
habit of troubleshooting multicast problems using specific sources and
groups. IMO, SAP itself is of only very limited use, and getting less useful
all the time.
It would be interesting to write a script to listen to SAP traffic and join
the announced groups to see which ones actually carry traffic; I'd guess
around half. And on top of that, the majority of 'interesting' multicast
traffic (from my perspective) is not announced by SAP. . .
Bill.
- Re: Cisco IPv4 Multicast Issue, (continued)
- Re: Cisco IPv4 Multicast Issue, Brent Draney, 05/02/2006
- Re: Cisco IPv4 Multicast Issue, ken lindahl, 05/02/2006
- Re: Cisco IPv4 Multicast Issue, John Kristoff, 05/02/2006
- Re: Cisco IPv4 Multicast Issue, Marshall Eubanks, 05/02/2006
- Re: Cisco IPv4 Multicast Issue, Tim Chown, 05/02/2006
- Re: Cisco IPv4 Multicast Issue, Bill Owens, 05/02/2006
- Re: Cisco IPv4 Multicast Issue, Tim Chown, 05/02/2006
- Re: Cisco IPv4 Multicast Issue, David Farmer, 05/02/2006
- Re: Cisco IPv4 Multicast Issue, Marshall Eubanks, 05/02/2006
- Re: Cisco IPv4 Multicast Issue, Stig Venaas, 05/02/2006
- Re: Cisco IPv4 Multicast Issue, christian . macnevin, 05/03/2006
- Re: Cisco IPv4 Multicast Issue, Jimmy Kyriannis, 05/02/2006
- Re: Cisco IPv4 Multicast Issue, John Kristoff, 05/02/2006
- Re: Cisco IPv4 Multicast Issue, Bill Owens, 05/02/2006
Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.16.