Shibboleth Developers

["Cantor, Scott E." <>]

> My immediate instinct is that would really help the usability of 
> centralized DS,
> potentially at the cost of SP's which do
> (multi-IdP) attribute aggregation (and who I'd assume would need to do their
> own discovery), but I'd like to get your input...

My only comment is that one of the continued debates is over whether users 
(meaning nobody who would be on this list) actually care about this, or in 
fact find it even more confusing to end up sent to a particular IdP in some 
cases but prompted in others. The consistency argument is that it's better to 
just be uniform in what you give the user in each case, even at the cost of 
an extra click.

-- Scott