perfsonar-dev - Re: [pS-dev] Java 0.1 (EGEE tag) vs. perfSONAR-1.0 RRD MA performance
Subject: perfsonar development work
List archive
- From: Joe Metzger <>
- To: Vedrin Jeliazkov <>
- Cc:
- Subject: Re: [pS-dev] Java 0.1 (EGEE tag) vs. perfSONAR-1.0 RRD MA performance
- Date: Thu, 24 Aug 2006 10:59:06 -0500
Vedrin,
It is still a bit early to test the 'Upgraded' ESnet MA.
It is not stable.
I am running FreeBSD on that server. Currently it is a very old version
(4.10) that isn't properly supported by the Tomcat ports package. Tomcat
5.0 installs fine but crashes after a couple of hours. Tomcat 5.5
doesn't install cleanly.
The OS will be upgraded before the end of the week, and this should
streamline a clean re-install of Tomcat, Axis & Exist and hopefully
the resulting server will be more stable.
I have not configured the MA to use the eXist DB yet.
--Joe
Vedrin Jeliazkov wrote:
Hi,
I've run some simple tests against the upgraded RRD MA at ESnet in an attempt
to compare its performance against the older release. Here are the timings
I've got:
1. One MetadataKeyRequest (summary) [sec]
2. Number of Interfaces (NoI)
3. (NoI x 2) SetupDataRequests (detailed summary) [sec]
4. Average SetupDataRequest [msec]
5. Average Link latency (RTT) [msec]
6. Implementation
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6)
ESNET 180 415 468 564 202 Java 0.1 (EGEE tag)
ESNET 296 419 1600 1909 206 perfSONAR-1.0
As you can see, the differences in the number of interfaces and the network
latency are insignificant, while MetadataKeyRequest's and SetupDataREquest's
processing time is much longer in the new service version, when compared to
the older one (multiplied by 1.6 and 3.4 respectively).
If the service is running on the same hardware platform, than we could
conclude that there is a significant performance loss in the new version,
which is most probably due to some newly introduced scalability issue. Perhaps
some more comprehensive tests should be run in order to understand and resolve
this issue.
Kind regards,
Vedrin
- Re: [pS-dev] Java 0.1 (EGEE tag) vs. perfSONAR-1.0 RRD MA performance, (continued)
- Re: [pS-dev] Java 0.1 (EGEE tag) vs. perfSONAR-1.0 RRD MA performance, Roman Lapacz, 08/24/2006
- Re: [pS-dev] Java 0.1 (EGEE tag) vs. perfSONAR-1.0 RRD MA performance, Loukik Kudarimoti, 08/24/2006
- Re: [pS-dev] Java 0.1 (EGEE tag) vs. perfSONAR-1.0 RRD MA performance, Vedrin Jeliazkov, 08/24/2006
- Re: [pS-dev] Java 0.1 (EGEE tag) vs. perfSONAR-1.0 RRD MA performance, Loukik Kudarimoti, 08/24/2006
- Re: [pS-dev] Java 0.1 (EGEE tag) vs. perfSONAR-1.0 RRD MA performance, Vedrin Jeliazkov, 08/24/2006
- Re: [pS-dev] Java 0.1 (EGEE tag) vs. perfSONAR-1.0 RRD MA performance, Vedrin Jeliazkov, 08/24/2006
- Re: [pS-dev] Java 0.1 (EGEE tag) vs. perfSONAR-1.0 RRD MA performance, Jeff W. Boote, 08/24/2006
- Re: [pS-dev] Java 0.1 (EGEE tag) vs. perfSONAR-1.0 RRD MA performance, Roman Lapacz, 08/25/2006
- Re: [pS-dev] Java 0.1 (EGEE tag) vs. perfSONAR-1.0 RRD MA performance, Vedrin Jeliazkov, 08/28/2006
- Re: [pS-dev] Java 0.1 (EGEE tag) vs. perfSONAR-1.0 RRD MA performance, Roman Lapacz, 08/28/2006
- Re: [pS-dev] Java 0.1 (EGEE tag) vs. perfSONAR-1.0 RRD MA performance, Maciej Glowiak, 08/30/2006
- Re: [pS-dev] Java 0.1 (EGEE tag) vs. perfSONAR-1.0 RRD MA performance, Vedrin Jeliazkov, 08/28/2006
- Re: [pS-dev] Java 0.1 (EGEE tag) vs. perfSONAR-1.0 RRD MA performance, Roman Lapacz, 08/25/2006
- Re: [pS-dev] Java 0.1 (EGEE tag) vs. perfSONAR-1.0 RRD MA performance, Loukik Kudarimoti, 08/24/2006
- Re: [pS-dev] Java 0.1 (EGEE tag) vs. perfSONAR-1.0 RRD MA performance, Joe Metzger, 08/24/2006
- Re: Java 0.1 (EGEE tag) vs. perfSONAR-1.0 RRD MA performance, Vedrin Jeliazkov, 08/30/2006
- Re: [pS-dev] Re: Java 0.1 (EGEE tag) vs. perfSONAR-1.0 RRD MA performance, Joe Metzger, 08/31/2006
- Re: [pS-dev] Re: Java 0.1 (EGEE tag) vs. perfSONAR-1.0 RRD MA performance, Jeff W. Boote, 08/31/2006
- Re: [pS-dev] Re: Java 0.1 (EGEE tag) vs. perfSONAR-1.0 RRD MA performance, Joe Metzger, 08/31/2006
- Re: [pS-dev] Java 0.1 (EGEE tag) vs. perfSONAR-1.0 RRD MA performance, Roman Lapacz, 08/24/2006
Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.16.