wg-multicast - Re: MSDP Storm
Subject: All things related to multicast
List archive
- From: Bill Owens <>
- To: ,
- Cc: , mbone mail list <>
- Subject: Re: MSDP Storm
- Date: Thu, 18 Jan 2001 08:35:11 -0500
At 5:25 -0500 1/18/01, Marshall Eubanks wrote:
Dear Michael;
Apparently a lot, at least for some routers -
we had 15,000 (S,G) at one time from Stanford, all within 2 or 3
minutes. How
long does it take one of these worms to scan through the entire
multicast /4 ?
Someone could look in the logs for the Stanford and UMass DR and see how
they faired.
The worm won't scan the entire space in order, only a random portion of it. From the INCIDENTS mailing list:
At 20:54 -0500 1/17/01, Daniel Martin wrote:
slim bones
<>
writes:
Ramen uses a binary called randb to generate class B nets to scan. I
just made it generate 1000 of these, they appear to be reasonably
scattered... however the first byte of the IP address was never less
than 13 nor greater than 242. Between those, addresses are fairly
evenly dispersed considering the small sample size. Of 1000 addresses
about 60 were in the range you identify. From what I've seen the
worm would not discriminate against multicast addresses.
For what it's worth, a disassembly of randb shows that the algorithm
used to choose network addresses is equivalent to:
(int)((rand()*230)/(MAXINT+1)) + 13
for the first byte and
(int)((rand()*254)/(MAXINT+1)) + 1
for the second.
In other words, just what you said; uniformly distributed in the first
byte from 13 to 242 and uniform in the second byte from 1 to 255.
I gather that if the worm were allowed to run free it would continue to scan forever, so it would eventually cover most of the multicast space.
Bill.
- RE: MSDP Storm, (continued)
- RE: MSDP Storm, Bill Owens, 01/17/2001
- RE: MSDP Storm, Bill Nickless, 01/17/2001
- Re: MSDP Storm, Marshall Eubanks, 01/17/2001
- Re: MSDP Storm, Bill Nickless, 01/17/2001
- Re: MSDP Storm, Marshall Eubanks, 01/17/2001
- Re: MSDP Storm, Bill Nickless, 01/17/2001
- Re: MSDP Storm, John Meylor, 01/18/2001
- Finding the worm, Bill Owens, 01/18/2001
- RE: MSDP Storm, Bill Owens, 01/17/2001
- RE: MSDP Storm, Michael Luby, 01/18/2001
- Re: MSDP Storm, Marshall Eubanks, 01/18/2001
- Re: MSDP Storm, Bill Owens, 01/18/2001
- Re: MSDP Storm, Dave Hartzell, 01/18/2001
- Re: MSDP Storm, Marshall Eubanks, 01/18/2001
- Re: MSDP Storm, Matthew Davy, 01/18/2001
- Re: MSDP Storm, Magnus Danielson, 01/18/2001
- Re: MSDP Storm, Marshall Eubanks, 01/18/2001
- RE: MSDP Storm, Mike Luby, 01/18/2001
- Re: MSDP Storm, Marshall Eubanks, 01/18/2001
- RE: MSDP Storm, Mike Luby, 01/18/2001
- Re: MSDP Storm, Marshall Eubanks, 01/18/2001
- Re: MSDP Storm, David Meyer, 01/18/2001
Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.16.