transport - Re: [transport] XCP reference
Subject: Transport protocols and bulk file transfer
List archive
- From: stanislav shalunov <>
- To:
- Subject: Re: [transport] XCP reference
- Date: 10 Dec 2004 02:47:01 -0500
"Injong Rhee"
<>
writes:
> Here is the reference about XCP.
>
> http://www.isi.edu/isi-xcp/share/extended.pdf
Injong,
Added the reference along with the reference to the internet-draft and
replaced the old text (``XCP can only be used if all routers on a path
support it, making it impractical in the near future'') with the
following:
XCP can only work if the bottleneck router supports it. (The
question of incremental XCP deployment appears to be open
\cite{falk-xcp-00,zhang-2004-xcp}, but the bottleneck router
will need to support XCP if XCP's control is to be effective.)
XCP will only become useful for the purposes of building a
deployable tool, then, when sufficient number of potential
bottleneck routers support it. As the IETF work on the XCP
specification is still in its early stages, most routers in
the field are unlikely to support XCP in the next few years.
Thus XCP, while an excellent congestion control scheme, does
not appear directly relevant to the need of building a file
transfer tool that would be usable in the near future.
Does this sound any better?
--
Stanislav Shalunov http://www.internet2.edu/~shalunov/
This message is designed to be viewed in boustrophedon.
- XCP reference, Injong Rhee, 12/03/2004
- Re: [transport] XCP reference, stanislav shalunov, 12/10/2004
- RE: [transport] XCP reference, Injong Rhee, 12/10/2004
- Re: [transport] XCP reference, stanislav shalunov, 12/10/2004
- RE: [transport] XCP reference, Injong Rhee, 12/10/2004
- Re: [transport] XCP reference, stanislav shalunov, 12/10/2004
Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.16.