Skip to Content.
Sympa Menu

perfsonar-dev - Re: [pS-dev] Problem with perfSONAR UI v 0.09

Subject: perfsonar development work

List archive

Re: [pS-dev] Problem with perfSONAR UI v 0.09


Chronological Thread 
  • From: "Vedrin Jeliazkov" <>
  • To: Giovanni Cesaroni <>
  • Cc: "'Perfsonar Development List'" <>
  • Subject: Re: [pS-dev] Problem with perfSONAR UI v 0.09
  • Date: Wed, 17 Jan 2007 15:53:29 +0200
  • Disposition-notification-to: "Vedrin Jeliazkov" <>

Hi Giovanni,

After a more thorough analysis today, we found that the RRD MA from the
perfSONAR-1.0 release returns Axis exceptions in random cases when aggregated
queries are sent either by the perfsonarUI-v0.09 client, or through the Visual
perfSONAR client (https://noc-mon.srce.hr/visual_perf/) testing ground
facility. An example aggregated query for 32 GARR interfaces (64 for both
directions) is attached, as well as the returned exception.

The problem is not present in the following cases:

1) the running target service version is newer than 1.0 (GEANT2, ISTF-J,
RedCLARA, RNP);

2) the query is not aggregated (or is only 'modestly' aggregated - e.g. in
GARR's case a query for 4 interfaces (8 directions) works fine);

We have implemented visualization of such exceptions through tooltips (over
N/A values) in perfsonarUI. When the tooltip says just "N/A" that means that
no exception was encountered and there's no data for the given time period. In
all other cases, the returned exception is printed out in the tooltip.

Having in mind the above mentioned points, as well as our current priorities,
we feel that it might be better to wait until the upcoming next perfSONAR
release becomes widely deployed and hopefully resolves this issue.

Meanwhile, affected services could be accessed through the following
alternative options:

1) http://perfsonar.acad.bg/perfsonar.jnlp - default options (-a32 -p1);

2) http://perfsonar.acad.bg/perfsonar-a4p1.jnlp (-a4 -p1);

3) http://perfsonar.acad.bg/perfsonar-a0p0.jnlp (-a0 -p0);

In particular (2) and especially (3) should run fine, but considerably slower.

Kind regards,
Vedrin

Giovanni Cesaroni
<>
wrote:

> Hi Vedrin,
> thank you for your prompt reply.
> I have some comments
>
> Vedrin Jeliazkov wrote:
> > Hi Giovanni,
> >
> > Many thanks for your report. The described behaviour is expected. It is
due
> to
> > a combination of conditions, which in some cases happen to be true
> > simultaneously.
> >
> > Here are some more details:
> >
> > 1) There are two interfaces in your MA, for which perfsonarUI-v0.08
produces
> > N/A utilization values in the summary table as well. The corresponding IP
> > addresses are:
> >
> > 192.168.11.1
> > 192.168.11.2
> >
> these are private IP addresses that I get automatically from a database.
> I'll add some lines to remove these addresses to my script which
> generate the xml registry file.
> > The reason for this is that the received response is empty. It might be
due
> to
> > some configuration problem.
> >
> > 2) There are another four interfaces in your MA, for which no fresh
> > utilization data is published since the end of November. The corresponding
> IP
> > addresses are:
> >
> > 193.206.134.174
> > 193.206.134.173
> > 193.206.134.170
> > 193.206.134.169
> >
> These ip addresses correspond to 4 dismissed links.
> I have to update the xml on eXist.
> > For these 4 interfaces PerfsonarUI-v0.08 reports 0 utilization, while
> > perfsonarUI-v0.09 reports N/A if there is no data for the selected time
> > period. The correct behaviour is the later, because the message content in
> > both cases is something like:
> >
> > <nmwg:message xmlns:nmwg="http://ggf.org/ns/nmwg/base/2.0/";
> > id="localhost.localdomain.-70321a6b:1102b61e8e7:-2023">
> > <nmwg:metadata id="meta117">
> > <netutil:subject
> > xmlns:netutil="http://ggf.org/ns/nmwg/characteristic/utilization/2.0/";
> > id="subj117">
> > <nmwgt:interface xmlns:nmwgt="http://ggf.org/ns/nmwg/topology/2.0/";>
> > <nmwgt:hostName>rt.na1.garr.net</nmwgt:hostName>
> > <nmwgt:ifName>at-3/0/0.160</nmwgt:ifName>
> > <nmwgt:ifDescription>PoP-NA -- PoP-NA1 Link
1</nmwgt:ifDescription>
> > <nmwgt:ifAddress type="ipv4">193.206.134.169</nmwgt:ifAddress>
> > <nmwgt:direction>in</nmwgt:direction>
> > <nmwgt:authRealm>GARR</nmwgt:authRealm>
> > <nmwgt:capacity>155000000</nmwgt:capacity>
> > </nmwgt:interface>
> > </netutil:subject>
> > <nmwg:eventType>utilization</nmwg:eventType>
> > </nmwg:metadata>
> > <nmwg:data id="localhost.localdomain.-70321a6b:1102b61e8e7:-2024"
> > metadataIdRef="meta117">
> > <nmwg:datum timeValue="1168952700" value="NaN" />
> > <nmwg:datum timeValue="1168953000" value="NaN" />
> > <nmwg:datum timeValue="1168953300" value="NaN" />
> > <nmwg:datum timeValue="1168953600" value="NaN" />
> > <nmwg:datum timeValue="1168953900" value="NaN" />
> > <nmwg:datum timeValue="1168954200" value="NaN" />
> > <nmwg:datum timeValue="1168954500" value="NaN" />
> > <nmwg:datum timeValue="1168954800" value="NaN" />
> > <nmwg:datum timeValue="1168955100" value="NaN" />
> > <nmwg:datum timeValue="1168955400" value="NaN" />
> > <nmwg:datum timeValue="1168955700" value="NaN" />
> > <nmwg:datum timeValue="1168956000" value="NaN" />
> > <nmwg:datum timeValue="1168956300" value="NaN" />
> > <nmwg:datum timeValue="1168956600" value="NaN" />
> > <nmwg:datum timeValue="1168956900" value="NaN" />
> > <nmwg:datum timeValue="1168957200" value="NaN" />
> > <nmwg:datum timeValue="1168957500" value="NaN" />
> > <nmwg:datum timeValue="1168957800" value="NaN" />
> > <nmwg:datum timeValue="1168958100" value="NaN" />
> > </nmwg:data>
> > </nmwg:message>
> >
> > In fact, perfsonarUI-v.08 used to replace NaN with 0, which is misleading
> and
> > undesirable.
> >
> I think there is something more besides points 3 and 4 (for perfsonar.jnlp).
> The problem appears with addresses like 193.206.134.53 .
> If I request data searching by interface IP, specifying the single IP
> address,
> I should not get any aggregation nor overloading problems, but still
> v0.09 (perfsonar.jnlp) doesn't work while v0.08 works.
>
> As you predicted, I found a different result with perfsonar-noapr.jnlp
> It works specifying the single IP address, but not requesting a retrive all.
>
> Regards,
> Giovanni
>
> > 3) When aggregation of requests is enabled in perfsonarUI-v0.09 (as it is
in
> > the default JNLP version available online), a problem with a single
> interface
> > in an aggregated query could invalidate the whole query and lead to
missing
> > info for correctly configured/reported interfaces, sharing the same
> aggregated
> > query/response. This is actually a protocol design issue, which needs to
be
> > addressed.
> >
> > 4) Certain services become easily overloaded when a high number of
parallel
> > (and/or aggregated) requests have to be processed. This is also an issue,
> > which has to be addressed by service developers. In cases when an answer
is
> > not received by the client for a given period of time, the corresponding
> > entries are marked as N/A. We could consider displaying another value in
> case
> > of timeouts.
> >
> > While playing with an alternative perfsonarUI-v0.09 setup, temporarily
> > available online here:
> >
> > http://perfsonar.acad.bg/perfsonar-noapr.jnlp
> >
> > we were able to get correct data for all your interfaces, except those
> > mentioned in (1). The difference is that this perfsonarUI-v0.09 instance
is
> > configured to avoid parallel and aggregated queries. In addition, a longer
> > time period for summary statistics has to be selected in order to get data
> for
> > the four interfaces mentioned in (2) - "Last 3 months" or "Last year".
> >
> > Best regards,
> > Vedrin
> >
> > Giovanni Cesaroni
> > <>
> > wrote:
> >
> >
> >> Hi all,
> >> I found a problem with the perfSONAR UI v 0.09.
> >> I don't know if it is a known issue.
> >> In the table "Select Interface" some links have an N/A value on
> >> Inbound/Outbound Utilization,
> >> while the utilization statistics are correct.
> >> The problem does not happen in the previous version.
> >> See the highlighted link in the images below.
> >>
> >> UI v 0.09
> >>
> >>
> >> UI v 0.08
> >>
> >>
> >> Regards,
> >> Giovanni
> >>
> >
> >
> >
> >
> >
>


<nmwg:message id="message1169031872" type="SetupDataRequest" xmlns:netutil="http://ggf.org/ns/nmwg/characteristic/utilization/2.0/"; xmlns:nmwg="http://ggf.org/ns/nmwg/base/2.0/"; xmlns:nmwgt="http://ggf.org/ns/nmwg/topology/2.0/"; xmlns:select="http://ggf.org/ns/nmwg/ops/select/2.0/";>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta_0in">
    <netutil:subject id="subject_1">
      <nmwgt:interface>
        <nmwgt:hostName>rc.pa1.garr.net</nmwgt:hostName>
        <nmwgt:ifName>AT0/0/0.173</nmwgt:ifName>
        <nmwgt:ifAddress type="ipv4">193.206.134.62</nmwgt:ifAddress>
        <nmwgt:direction>in</nmwgt:direction>
      </nmwgt:interface>
    </netutil:subject>
    <nmwg:eventType>utilization</nmwg:eventType>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta2_0in">
    <select:subject id="subject1_2" metadataIdRef="meta_0in"/>
    <nmwg:eventType>select</nmwg:eventType>
    <select:parameters id="param_3">
      <nmwg:parameter name="startTime">1169026470</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="endTime">1169031870</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="consolidationFunction">AVERAGE</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="resolution">300</nmwg:parameter>
    </select:parameters>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:data id="data_0in" metadataIdRef="meta2_0in"/>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta_0out">
    <netutil:subject id="subject_3">
      <nmwgt:interface>
        <nmwgt:hostName>rc.pa1.garr.net</nmwgt:hostName>
        <nmwgt:ifName>AT0/0/0.173</nmwgt:ifName>
        <nmwgt:ifAddress type="ipv4">193.206.134.62</nmwgt:ifAddress>
        <nmwgt:direction>out</nmwgt:direction>
      </nmwgt:interface>
    </netutil:subject>
    <nmwg:eventType>utilization</nmwg:eventType>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta2_0out">
    <select:subject id="subject1_4" metadataIdRef="meta_0out"/>
    <nmwg:eventType>select</nmwg:eventType>
    <select:parameters id="param_5">
      <nmwg:parameter name="startTime">1169026470</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="endTime">1169031870</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="consolidationFunction">AVERAGE</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="resolution">300</nmwg:parameter>
    </select:parameters>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:data id="data_0out" metadataIdRef="meta2_0out"/>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta_1in">
    <netutil:subject id="subject_5">
      <nmwgt:interface>
        <nmwgt:hostName>rt.rm2.garr.net</nmwgt:hostName>
        <nmwgt:ifName>at-2/0/0.152</nmwgt:ifName>
        <nmwgt:ifAddress type="ipv4">193.206.134.105</nmwgt:ifAddress>
        <nmwgt:direction>in</nmwgt:direction>
      </nmwgt:interface>
    </netutil:subject>
    <nmwg:eventType>utilization</nmwg:eventType>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta2_1in">
    <select:subject id="subject1_6" metadataIdRef="meta_1in"/>
    <nmwg:eventType>select</nmwg:eventType>
    <select:parameters id="param_7">
      <nmwg:parameter name="startTime">1169026470</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="endTime">1169031870</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="consolidationFunction">AVERAGE</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="resolution">300</nmwg:parameter>
    </select:parameters>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:data id="data_1in" metadataIdRef="meta2_1in"/>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta_1out">
    <netutil:subject id="subject_7">
      <nmwgt:interface>
        <nmwgt:hostName>rt.rm2.garr.net</nmwgt:hostName>
        <nmwgt:ifName>at-2/0/0.152</nmwgt:ifName>
        <nmwgt:ifAddress type="ipv4">193.206.134.105</nmwgt:ifAddress>
        <nmwgt:direction>out</nmwgt:direction>
      </nmwgt:interface>
    </netutil:subject>
    <nmwg:eventType>utilization</nmwg:eventType>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta2_1out">
    <select:subject id="subject1_8" metadataIdRef="meta_1out"/>
    <nmwg:eventType>select</nmwg:eventType>
    <select:parameters id="param_9">
      <nmwg:parameter name="startTime">1169026470</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="endTime">1169031870</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="consolidationFunction">AVERAGE</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="resolution">300</nmwg:parameter>
    </select:parameters>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:data id="data_1out" metadataIdRef="meta2_1out"/>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta_2in">
    <netutil:subject id="subject_9">
      <nmwgt:interface>
        <nmwgt:hostName>rt.rm1.garr.net</nmwgt:hostName>
        <nmwgt:ifName>PO4/1</nmwgt:ifName>
        <nmwgt:ifAddress type="ipv4">193.206.134.246</nmwgt:ifAddress>
        <nmwgt:direction>in</nmwgt:direction>
      </nmwgt:interface>
    </netutil:subject>
    <nmwg:eventType>utilization</nmwg:eventType>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta2_2in">
    <select:subject id="subject1_10" metadataIdRef="meta_2in"/>
    <nmwg:eventType>select</nmwg:eventType>
    <select:parameters id="param_11">
      <nmwg:parameter name="startTime">1169026470</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="endTime">1169031870</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="consolidationFunction">AVERAGE</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="resolution">300</nmwg:parameter>
    </select:parameters>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:data id="data_2in" metadataIdRef="meta2_2in"/>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta_2out">
    <netutil:subject id="subject_11">
      <nmwgt:interface>
        <nmwgt:hostName>rt.rm1.garr.net</nmwgt:hostName>
        <nmwgt:ifName>PO4/1</nmwgt:ifName>
        <nmwgt:ifAddress type="ipv4">193.206.134.246</nmwgt:ifAddress>
        <nmwgt:direction>out</nmwgt:direction>
      </nmwgt:interface>
    </netutil:subject>
    <nmwg:eventType>utilization</nmwg:eventType>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta2_2out">
    <select:subject id="subject1_12" metadataIdRef="meta_2out"/>
    <nmwg:eventType>select</nmwg:eventType>
    <select:parameters id="param_13">
      <nmwg:parameter name="startTime">1169026470</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="endTime">1169031870</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="consolidationFunction">AVERAGE</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="resolution">300</nmwg:parameter>
    </select:parameters>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:data id="data_2out" metadataIdRef="meta2_2out"/>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta_3in">
    <netutil:subject id="subject_13">
      <nmwgt:interface>
        <nmwgt:hostName>rt1.mi1.garr.net</nmwgt:hostName>
        <nmwgt:ifName>so-2/0/0.0</nmwgt:ifName>
        <nmwgt:ifAddress type="ipv4">193.206.134.45</nmwgt:ifAddress>
        <nmwgt:direction>in</nmwgt:direction>
      </nmwgt:interface>
    </netutil:subject>
    <nmwg:eventType>utilization</nmwg:eventType>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta2_3in">
    <select:subject id="subject1_14" metadataIdRef="meta_3in"/>
    <nmwg:eventType>select</nmwg:eventType>
    <select:parameters id="param_15">
      <nmwg:parameter name="startTime">1169026470</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="endTime">1169031870</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="consolidationFunction">AVERAGE</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="resolution">300</nmwg:parameter>
    </select:parameters>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:data id="data_3in" metadataIdRef="meta2_3in"/>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta_3out">
    <netutil:subject id="subject_15">
      <nmwgt:interface>
        <nmwgt:hostName>rt1.mi1.garr.net</nmwgt:hostName>
        <nmwgt:ifName>so-2/0/0.0</nmwgt:ifName>
        <nmwgt:ifAddress type="ipv4">193.206.134.45</nmwgt:ifAddress>
        <nmwgt:direction>out</nmwgt:direction>
      </nmwgt:interface>
    </netutil:subject>
    <nmwg:eventType>utilization</nmwg:eventType>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta2_3out">
    <select:subject id="subject1_16" metadataIdRef="meta_3out"/>
    <nmwg:eventType>select</nmwg:eventType>
    <select:parameters id="param_17">
      <nmwg:parameter name="startTime">1169026470</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="endTime">1169031870</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="consolidationFunction">AVERAGE</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="resolution">300</nmwg:parameter>
    </select:parameters>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:data id="data_3out" metadataIdRef="meta2_3out"/>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta_4in">
    <netutil:subject id="subject_17">
      <nmwgt:interface>
        <nmwgt:hostName>rc.le.garr.net</nmwgt:hostName>
        <nmwgt:ifName>ATM1/0.285-aal5 layer</nmwgt:ifName>
        <nmwgt:ifAddress type="ipv4">193.206.141.54</nmwgt:ifAddress>
        <nmwgt:direction>in</nmwgt:direction>
      </nmwgt:interface>
    </netutil:subject>
    <nmwg:eventType>utilization</nmwg:eventType>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta2_4in">
    <select:subject id="subject1_18" metadataIdRef="meta_4in"/>
    <nmwg:eventType>select</nmwg:eventType>
    <select:parameters id="param_19">
      <nmwg:parameter name="startTime">1169026470</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="endTime">1169031870</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="consolidationFunction">AVERAGE</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="resolution">300</nmwg:parameter>
    </select:parameters>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:data id="data_4in" metadataIdRef="meta2_4in"/>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta_4out">
    <netutil:subject id="subject_19">
      <nmwgt:interface>
        <nmwgt:hostName>rc.le.garr.net</nmwgt:hostName>
        <nmwgt:ifName>ATM1/0.285-aal5 layer</nmwgt:ifName>
        <nmwgt:ifAddress type="ipv4">193.206.141.54</nmwgt:ifAddress>
        <nmwgt:direction>out</nmwgt:direction>
      </nmwgt:interface>
    </netutil:subject>
    <nmwg:eventType>utilization</nmwg:eventType>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta2_4out">
    <select:subject id="subject1_20" metadataIdRef="meta_4out"/>
    <nmwg:eventType>select</nmwg:eventType>
    <select:parameters id="param_21">
      <nmwg:parameter name="startTime">1169026470</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="endTime">1169031870</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="consolidationFunction">AVERAGE</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="resolution">300</nmwg:parameter>
    </select:parameters>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:data id="data_4out" metadataIdRef="meta2_4out"/>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta_5in">
    <netutil:subject id="subject_21">
      <nmwgt:interface>
        <nmwgt:hostName>rt1.bo1.garr.net</nmwgt:hostName>
        <nmwgt:ifName>so-1/3/0.0</nmwgt:ifName>
        <nmwgt:ifAddress type="ipv4">193.206.134.238</nmwgt:ifAddress>
        <nmwgt:direction>in</nmwgt:direction>
      </nmwgt:interface>
    </netutil:subject>
    <nmwg:eventType>utilization</nmwg:eventType>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta2_5in">
    <select:subject id="subject1_22" metadataIdRef="meta_5in"/>
    <nmwg:eventType>select</nmwg:eventType>
    <select:parameters id="param_23">
      <nmwg:parameter name="startTime">1169026470</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="endTime">1169031870</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="consolidationFunction">AVERAGE</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="resolution">300</nmwg:parameter>
    </select:parameters>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:data id="data_5in" metadataIdRef="meta2_5in"/>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta_5out">
    <netutil:subject id="subject_23">
      <nmwgt:interface>
        <nmwgt:hostName>rt1.bo1.garr.net</nmwgt:hostName>
        <nmwgt:ifName>so-1/3/0.0</nmwgt:ifName>
        <nmwgt:ifAddress type="ipv4">193.206.134.238</nmwgt:ifAddress>
        <nmwgt:direction>out</nmwgt:direction>
      </nmwgt:interface>
    </netutil:subject>
    <nmwg:eventType>utilization</nmwg:eventType>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta2_5out">
    <select:subject id="subject1_24" metadataIdRef="meta_5out"/>
    <nmwg:eventType>select</nmwg:eventType>
    <select:parameters id="param_25">
      <nmwg:parameter name="startTime">1169026470</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="endTime">1169031870</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="consolidationFunction">AVERAGE</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="resolution">300</nmwg:parameter>
    </select:parameters>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:data id="data_5out" metadataIdRef="meta2_5out"/>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta_6in">
    <netutil:subject id="subject_25">
      <nmwgt:interface>
        <nmwgt:hostName>rc.na.garr.net</nmwgt:hostName>
        <nmwgt:ifName>AT1/0/0.260</nmwgt:ifName>
        <nmwgt:ifAddress type="ipv4">193.206.134.174</nmwgt:ifAddress>
        <nmwgt:direction>in</nmwgt:direction>
      </nmwgt:interface>
    </netutil:subject>
    <nmwg:eventType>utilization</nmwg:eventType>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta2_6in">
    <select:subject id="subject1_26" metadataIdRef="meta_6in"/>
    <nmwg:eventType>select</nmwg:eventType>
    <select:parameters id="param_27">
      <nmwg:parameter name="startTime">1169026470</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="endTime">1169031870</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="consolidationFunction">AVERAGE</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="resolution">300</nmwg:parameter>
    </select:parameters>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:data id="data_6in" metadataIdRef="meta2_6in"/>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta_6out">
    <netutil:subject id="subject_27">
      <nmwgt:interface>
        <nmwgt:hostName>rc.na.garr.net</nmwgt:hostName>
        <nmwgt:ifName>AT1/0/0.260</nmwgt:ifName>
        <nmwgt:ifAddress type="ipv4">193.206.134.174</nmwgt:ifAddress>
        <nmwgt:direction>out</nmwgt:direction>
      </nmwgt:interface>
    </netutil:subject>
    <nmwg:eventType>utilization</nmwg:eventType>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta2_6out">
    <select:subject id="subject1_28" metadataIdRef="meta_6out"/>
    <nmwg:eventType>select</nmwg:eventType>
    <select:parameters id="param_29">
      <nmwg:parameter name="startTime">1169026470</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="endTime">1169031870</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="consolidationFunction">AVERAGE</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="resolution">300</nmwg:parameter>
    </select:parameters>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:data id="data_6out" metadataIdRef="meta2_6out"/>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta_7in">
    <netutil:subject id="subject_29">
      <nmwgt:interface>
        <nmwgt:hostName>rt.pd1.garr.net</nmwgt:hostName>
        <nmwgt:ifName>at-2/0/1.123</nmwgt:ifName>
        <nmwgt:ifAddress type="ipv4">193.206.141.29</nmwgt:ifAddress>
        <nmwgt:direction>in</nmwgt:direction>
      </nmwgt:interface>
    </netutil:subject>
    <nmwg:eventType>utilization</nmwg:eventType>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta2_7in">
    <select:subject id="subject1_30" metadataIdRef="meta_7in"/>
    <nmwg:eventType>select</nmwg:eventType>
    <select:parameters id="param_31">
      <nmwg:parameter name="startTime">1169026470</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="endTime">1169031870</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="consolidationFunction">AVERAGE</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="resolution">300</nmwg:parameter>
    </select:parameters>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:data id="data_7in" metadataIdRef="meta2_7in"/>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta_7out">
    <netutil:subject id="subject_31">
      <nmwgt:interface>
        <nmwgt:hostName>rt.pd1.garr.net</nmwgt:hostName>
        <nmwgt:ifName>at-2/0/1.123</nmwgt:ifName>
        <nmwgt:ifAddress type="ipv4">193.206.141.29</nmwgt:ifAddress>
        <nmwgt:direction>out</nmwgt:direction>
      </nmwgt:interface>
    </netutil:subject>
    <nmwg:eventType>utilization</nmwg:eventType>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta2_7out">
    <select:subject id="subject1_32" metadataIdRef="meta_7out"/>
    <nmwg:eventType>select</nmwg:eventType>
    <select:parameters id="param_33">
      <nmwg:parameter name="startTime">1169026470</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="endTime">1169031870</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="consolidationFunction">AVERAGE</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="resolution">300</nmwg:parameter>
    </select:parameters>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:data id="data_7out" metadataIdRef="meta2_7out"/>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta_8in">
    <netutil:subject id="subject_33">
      <nmwgt:interface>
        <nmwgt:hostName>rc.ge1.garr.net</nmwgt:hostName>
        <nmwgt:ifName>ATM1/1/0.101-aal5 layer</nmwgt:ifName>
        <nmwgt:ifAddress type="ipv4">193.206.134.250</nmwgt:ifAddress>
        <nmwgt:direction>in</nmwgt:direction>
      </nmwgt:interface>
    </netutil:subject>
    <nmwg:eventType>utilization</nmwg:eventType>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta2_8in">
    <select:subject id="subject1_34" metadataIdRef="meta_8in"/>
    <nmwg:eventType>select</nmwg:eventType>
    <select:parameters id="param_35">
      <nmwg:parameter name="startTime">1169026470</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="endTime">1169031870</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="consolidationFunction">AVERAGE</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="resolution">300</nmwg:parameter>
    </select:parameters>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:data id="data_8in" metadataIdRef="meta2_8in"/>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta_8out">
    <netutil:subject id="subject_35">
      <nmwgt:interface>
        <nmwgt:hostName>rc.ge1.garr.net</nmwgt:hostName>
        <nmwgt:ifName>ATM1/1/0.101-aal5 layer</nmwgt:ifName>
        <nmwgt:ifAddress type="ipv4">193.206.134.250</nmwgt:ifAddress>
        <nmwgt:direction>out</nmwgt:direction>
      </nmwgt:interface>
    </netutil:subject>
    <nmwg:eventType>utilization</nmwg:eventType>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta2_8out">
    <select:subject id="subject1_36" metadataIdRef="meta_8out"/>
    <nmwg:eventType>select</nmwg:eventType>
    <select:parameters id="param_37">
      <nmwg:parameter name="startTime">1169026470</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="endTime">1169031870</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="consolidationFunction">AVERAGE</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="resolution">300</nmwg:parameter>
    </select:parameters>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:data id="data_8out" metadataIdRef="meta2_8out"/>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta_9in">
    <netutil:subject id="subject_37">
      <nmwgt:interface>
        <nmwgt:hostName>rc.ge1.garr.net</nmwgt:hostName>
        <nmwgt:ifName>ATM0/1/0.100-aal5 layer</nmwgt:ifName>
        <nmwgt:ifAddress type="ipv4">193.206.134.210</nmwgt:ifAddress>
        <nmwgt:direction>in</nmwgt:direction>
      </nmwgt:interface>
    </netutil:subject>
    <nmwg:eventType>utilization</nmwg:eventType>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta2_9in">
    <select:subject id="subject1_38" metadataIdRef="meta_9in"/>
    <nmwg:eventType>select</nmwg:eventType>
    <select:parameters id="param_39">
      <nmwg:parameter name="startTime">1169026470</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="endTime">1169031870</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="consolidationFunction">AVERAGE</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="resolution">300</nmwg:parameter>
    </select:parameters>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:data id="data_9in" metadataIdRef="meta2_9in"/>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta_9out">
    <netutil:subject id="subject_39">
      <nmwgt:interface>
        <nmwgt:hostName>rc.ge1.garr.net</nmwgt:hostName>
        <nmwgt:ifName>ATM0/1/0.100-aal5 layer</nmwgt:ifName>
        <nmwgt:ifAddress type="ipv4">193.206.134.210</nmwgt:ifAddress>
        <nmwgt:direction>out</nmwgt:direction>
      </nmwgt:interface>
    </netutil:subject>
    <nmwg:eventType>utilization</nmwg:eventType>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta2_9out">
    <select:subject id="subject1_40" metadataIdRef="meta_9out"/>
    <nmwg:eventType>select</nmwg:eventType>
    <select:parameters id="param_41">
      <nmwg:parameter name="startTime">1169026470</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="endTime">1169031870</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="consolidationFunction">AVERAGE</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="resolution">300</nmwg:parameter>
    </select:parameters>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:data id="data_9out" metadataIdRef="meta2_9out"/>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta_10in">
    <netutil:subject id="subject_41">
      <nmwgt:interface>
        <nmwgt:hostName>rc.sa.garr.net</nmwgt:hostName>
        <nmwgt:ifName>AT0/0/0.1</nmwgt:ifName>
        <nmwgt:ifAddress type="ipv4">193.206.141.10</nmwgt:ifAddress>
        <nmwgt:direction>in</nmwgt:direction>
      </nmwgt:interface>
    </netutil:subject>
    <nmwg:eventType>utilization</nmwg:eventType>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta2_10in">
    <select:subject id="subject1_42" metadataIdRef="meta_10in"/>
    <nmwg:eventType>select</nmwg:eventType>
    <select:parameters id="param_43">
      <nmwg:parameter name="startTime">1169026470</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="endTime">1169031870</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="consolidationFunction">AVERAGE</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="resolution">300</nmwg:parameter>
    </select:parameters>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:data id="data_10in" metadataIdRef="meta2_10in"/>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta_10out">
    <netutil:subject id="subject_43">
      <nmwgt:interface>
        <nmwgt:hostName>rc.sa.garr.net</nmwgt:hostName>
        <nmwgt:ifName>AT0/0/0.1</nmwgt:ifName>
        <nmwgt:ifAddress type="ipv4">193.206.141.10</nmwgt:ifAddress>
        <nmwgt:direction>out</nmwgt:direction>
      </nmwgt:interface>
    </netutil:subject>
    <nmwg:eventType>utilization</nmwg:eventType>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta2_10out">
    <select:subject id="subject1_44" metadataIdRef="meta_10out"/>
    <nmwg:eventType>select</nmwg:eventType>
    <select:parameters id="param_45">
      <nmwg:parameter name="startTime">1169026470</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="endTime">1169031870</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="consolidationFunction">AVERAGE</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="resolution">300</nmwg:parameter>
    </select:parameters>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:data id="data_10out" metadataIdRef="meta2_10out"/>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta_11in">
    <netutil:subject id="subject_45">
      <nmwgt:interface>
        <nmwgt:hostName>rt.bo1.garr.net</nmwgt:hostName>
        <nmwgt:ifName>PO1/2</nmwgt:ifName>
        <nmwgt:ifAddress type="ipv4">193.206.134.237</nmwgt:ifAddress>
        <nmwgt:direction>in</nmwgt:direction>
      </nmwgt:interface>
    </netutil:subject>
    <nmwg:eventType>utilization</nmwg:eventType>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta2_11in">
    <select:subject id="subject1_46" metadataIdRef="meta_11in"/>
    <nmwg:eventType>select</nmwg:eventType>
    <select:parameters id="param_47">
      <nmwg:parameter name="startTime">1169026470</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="endTime">1169031870</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="consolidationFunction">AVERAGE</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="resolution">300</nmwg:parameter>
    </select:parameters>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:data id="data_11in" metadataIdRef="meta2_11in"/>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta_11out">
    <netutil:subject id="subject_47">
      <nmwgt:interface>
        <nmwgt:hostName>rt.bo1.garr.net</nmwgt:hostName>
        <nmwgt:ifName>PO1/2</nmwgt:ifName>
        <nmwgt:ifAddress type="ipv4">193.206.134.237</nmwgt:ifAddress>
        <nmwgt:direction>out</nmwgt:direction>
      </nmwgt:interface>
    </netutil:subject>
    <nmwg:eventType>utilization</nmwg:eventType>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta2_11out">
    <select:subject id="subject1_48" metadataIdRef="meta_11out"/>
    <nmwg:eventType>select</nmwg:eventType>
    <select:parameters id="param_49">
      <nmwg:parameter name="startTime">1169026470</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="endTime">1169031870</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="consolidationFunction">AVERAGE</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="resolution">300</nmwg:parameter>
    </select:parameters>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:data id="data_11out" metadataIdRef="meta2_11out"/>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta_12in">
    <netutil:subject id="subject_49">
      <nmwgt:interface>
        <nmwgt:hostName>rt.rm1.garr.net</nmwgt:hostName>
        <nmwgt:ifName>PO11/0</nmwgt:ifName>
        <nmwgt:ifAddress type="ipv4">193.206.134.49</nmwgt:ifAddress>
        <nmwgt:direction>in</nmwgt:direction>
      </nmwgt:interface>
    </netutil:subject>
    <nmwg:eventType>utilization</nmwg:eventType>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta2_12in">
    <select:subject id="subject1_50" metadataIdRef="meta_12in"/>
    <nmwg:eventType>select</nmwg:eventType>
    <select:parameters id="param_51">
      <nmwg:parameter name="startTime">1169026470</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="endTime">1169031870</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="consolidationFunction">AVERAGE</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="resolution">300</nmwg:parameter>
    </select:parameters>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:data id="data_12in" metadataIdRef="meta2_12in"/>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta_12out">
    <netutil:subject id="subject_51">
      <nmwgt:interface>
        <nmwgt:hostName>rt.rm1.garr.net</nmwgt:hostName>
        <nmwgt:ifName>PO11/0</nmwgt:ifName>
        <nmwgt:ifAddress type="ipv4">193.206.134.49</nmwgt:ifAddress>
        <nmwgt:direction>out</nmwgt:direction>
      </nmwgt:interface>
    </netutil:subject>
    <nmwg:eventType>utilization</nmwg:eventType>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta2_12out">
    <select:subject id="subject1_52" metadataIdRef="meta_12out"/>
    <nmwg:eventType>select</nmwg:eventType>
    <select:parameters id="param_53">
      <nmwg:parameter name="startTime">1169026470</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="endTime">1169031870</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="consolidationFunction">AVERAGE</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="resolution">300</nmwg:parameter>
    </select:parameters>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:data id="data_12out" metadataIdRef="meta2_12out"/>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta_13in">
    <netutil:subject id="subject_53">
      <nmwgt:interface>
        <nmwgt:hostName>rt.rm1.garr.net</nmwgt:hostName>
        <nmwgt:ifName>PO4/0</nmwgt:ifName>
        <nmwgt:ifAddress type="ipv4">193.206.134.53</nmwgt:ifAddress>
        <nmwgt:direction>in</nmwgt:direction>
      </nmwgt:interface>
    </netutil:subject>
    <nmwg:eventType>utilization</nmwg:eventType>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta2_13in">
    <select:subject id="subject1_54" metadataIdRef="meta_13in"/>
    <nmwg:eventType>select</nmwg:eventType>
    <select:parameters id="param_55">
      <nmwg:parameter name="startTime">1169026470</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="endTime">1169031870</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="consolidationFunction">AVERAGE</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="resolution">300</nmwg:parameter>
    </select:parameters>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:data id="data_13in" metadataIdRef="meta2_13in"/>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta_13out">
    <netutil:subject id="subject_55">
      <nmwgt:interface>
        <nmwgt:hostName>rt.rm1.garr.net</nmwgt:hostName>
        <nmwgt:ifName>PO4/0</nmwgt:ifName>
        <nmwgt:ifAddress type="ipv4">193.206.134.53</nmwgt:ifAddress>
        <nmwgt:direction>out</nmwgt:direction>
      </nmwgt:interface>
    </netutil:subject>
    <nmwg:eventType>utilization</nmwg:eventType>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta2_13out">
    <select:subject id="subject1_56" metadataIdRef="meta_13out"/>
    <nmwg:eventType>select</nmwg:eventType>
    <select:parameters id="param_57">
      <nmwg:parameter name="startTime">1169026470</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="endTime">1169031870</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="consolidationFunction">AVERAGE</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="resolution">300</nmwg:parameter>
    </select:parameters>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:data id="data_13out" metadataIdRef="meta2_13out"/>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta_14in">
    <netutil:subject id="subject_57">
      <nmwgt:interface>
        <nmwgt:hostName>rt.ba1.garr.net</nmwgt:hostName>
        <nmwgt:ifName>so-1/0/0.0</nmwgt:ifName>
        <nmwgt:ifAddress type="ipv4">193.206.134.78</nmwgt:ifAddress>
        <nmwgt:direction>in</nmwgt:direction>
      </nmwgt:interface>
    </netutil:subject>
    <nmwg:eventType>utilization</nmwg:eventType>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta2_14in">
    <select:subject id="subject1_58" metadataIdRef="meta_14in"/>
    <nmwg:eventType>select</nmwg:eventType>
    <select:parameters id="param_59">
      <nmwg:parameter name="startTime">1169026470</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="endTime">1169031870</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="consolidationFunction">AVERAGE</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="resolution">300</nmwg:parameter>
    </select:parameters>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:data id="data_14in" metadataIdRef="meta2_14in"/>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta_14out">
    <netutil:subject id="subject_59">
      <nmwgt:interface>
        <nmwgt:hostName>rt.ba1.garr.net</nmwgt:hostName>
        <nmwgt:ifName>so-1/0/0.0</nmwgt:ifName>
        <nmwgt:ifAddress type="ipv4">193.206.134.78</nmwgt:ifAddress>
        <nmwgt:direction>out</nmwgt:direction>
      </nmwgt:interface>
    </netutil:subject>
    <nmwg:eventType>utilization</nmwg:eventType>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta2_14out">
    <select:subject id="subject1_60" metadataIdRef="meta_14out"/>
    <nmwg:eventType>select</nmwg:eventType>
    <select:parameters id="param_61">
      <nmwg:parameter name="startTime">1169026470</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="endTime">1169031870</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="consolidationFunction">AVERAGE</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="resolution">300</nmwg:parameter>
    </select:parameters>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:data id="data_14out" metadataIdRef="meta2_14out"/>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta_15in">
    <netutil:subject id="subject_61">
      <nmwgt:interface>
        <nmwgt:hostName>rt.na1.garr.net</nmwgt:hostName>
        <nmwgt:ifName>at-3/0/0.260</nmwgt:ifName>
        <nmwgt:ifAddress type="ipv4">193.206.134.173</nmwgt:ifAddress>
        <nmwgt:direction>in</nmwgt:direction>
      </nmwgt:interface>
    </netutil:subject>
    <nmwg:eventType>utilization</nmwg:eventType>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta2_15in">
    <select:subject id="subject1_62" metadataIdRef="meta_15in"/>
    <nmwg:eventType>select</nmwg:eventType>
    <select:parameters id="param_63">
      <nmwg:parameter name="startTime">1169026470</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="endTime">1169031870</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="consolidationFunction">AVERAGE</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="resolution">300</nmwg:parameter>
    </select:parameters>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:data id="data_15in" metadataIdRef="meta2_15in"/>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta_15out">
    <netutil:subject id="subject_63">
      <nmwgt:interface>
        <nmwgt:hostName>rt.na1.garr.net</nmwgt:hostName>
        <nmwgt:ifName>at-3/0/0.260</nmwgt:ifName>
        <nmwgt:ifAddress type="ipv4">193.206.134.173</nmwgt:ifAddress>
        <nmwgt:direction>out</nmwgt:direction>
      </nmwgt:interface>
    </netutil:subject>
    <nmwg:eventType>utilization</nmwg:eventType>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:metadata id="meta2_15out">
    <select:subject id="subject1_64" metadataIdRef="meta_15out"/>
    <nmwg:eventType>select</nmwg:eventType>
    <select:parameters id="param_65">
      <nmwg:parameter name="startTime">1169026470</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="endTime">1169031870</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="consolidationFunction">AVERAGE</nmwg:parameter>
      <nmwg:parameter name="resolution">300</nmwg:parameter>
    </select:parameters>
  </nmwg:metadata>
  <nmwg:data id="data_15out" metadataIdRef="meta2_15out"/>
</nmwg:message>
<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><soapenv:Envelope xmlns:soapenv="http://schemas.xmlsoap.org/soap/envelope/"; xmlns:xsd="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema"; xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance";><soapenv:Body><soapenv:Fault><faultcode>soapenv:Server.userException</faultcode><faultstring>org.perfsonar.service.commons.exceptions.SystemException: [unknown]: RRDStorageManager.rrdFetch: Cannot retrieve data from rrdjtool library: RRDFETCH failed: end time: did you really mean month 9031870?</faultstring><detail><ns1:hostname xmlns:ns1="http://xml.apache.org/axis/";>srv4</ns1:hostname></detail></soapenv:Fault></soapenv:Body></soapenv:Envelope>



Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.16.

Top of Page