Skip to Content.
Sympa Menu

layer3communitygroup - Re: Fwd: Layer 3 Community Group: Endorsement of Report last call

Subject: NAOPpag Subcommittee

List archive

Re: Fwd: Layer 3 Community Group: Endorsement of Report last call

Chronological Thread 
  • From: Michael Sinatra <>
  • To: Linda Roos <>, "" <>
  • Subject: Re: Fwd: Layer 3 Community Group: Endorsement of Report last call
  • Date: Fri, 24 Apr 2015 15:41:00 -0700

I looked at the document that Chris Robb sent out this week. I endorse
and support that document, with the following comment, speaking as an
individual member of the Future Peering Committee:

"I wholeheartedly support Internet2's efforts at creating a virtual
separation of TRCPS and R&E traffic, to replace the current physical
separation, and I believe this is consistent with the Future Peering
Committee's vision. I also believe that the Internet2 and IU
engineering staff have the flexibility to maintain a physical
separation, where the marginal costs versus marginal benefits do not
merit virtualization of a particular component. I do not interpret the
vision of the Future Peering Committee as mandating virtualization for
its own sake, but rather as suggesting virtualiztion as a cost-saving
measure to be implemented at the discretion of the relevant Internet2
engineering staff. I believe the current report is consistent with this


On 04/24/15 07:43, Linda Roos wrote:
> Hi All,
> Please see note from Paul Schopis. His email application chose an email
> with “request” in it so not sure that you all will see this. Just
> ensuring that you do. Thanks.
> Linda
> Begin forwarded message:
>> *From: *"Schopis, Paul"
>> <
>> <mailto:>>
>> *Subject: * *Endorsement of Report last call*
>> *Date: *April 24, 2015 at 10:23:51 AM EDT
>> *To:
>> *"
>> <mailto:>"
>> <
>> <mailto:>>
>> All,
>> Thank you for your participation in the group. As a practical matter,
>> we would like to present the report on Monday to the NAOP as promised.
>> As things stand, we have a majority of committee members endorsing the
>> report either before or including Michael’s suggestions. John has
>> offered some other changes but we are basically out of time.
>> Here is how I suggest we proceed: we will count you endorsement as a
>> thumbs up, i.e. you are still endorsing unless you tell us you are
>> withdrawing your endorsement. _If you wish to withdraw your
>> endorsement please do so COB today_. Similarly, if you have not yet
>> voted, please vote yeah or nay.
>> I do want to offer the NAOP an honest accounting so please help us do
>> that.
>> Be well,
>> Paul
>> ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
>> Paul Schopis
>> CTO
>> OARnet
>> 1224 Kinnear Rd
>> Columbus OH 43221
>> 614-292-1956
> --
> Linda Roos
> Director, State and Regional Networks
> Internet2
> <mailto:>
> desk: 812-558-0615
> mobile: 614-209-8125

Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.16.

Top of Page